AZPlerp.comAZPlerp.com
A.Z. Plerp Company
CLUSTER PUZZLE SALES HISTORY ON EBAY
At the tail end of 2002 I first became aware of Cluster Puzzles being actively traded on eBay. That revelation alone was responsible for the creation of the A.Z. Plerp Company, its offerings and this website. Now, 60 years after their creation, Cluster Puzzles have a growing base of dedicated collectors and fans.
Since that time I've kept a log of all the Cluster Puzzle auction appearances I could find on eBay and of the auction results. (I know...get a life, right?) The fact is that this process has painted a more accurate picture of how the various different Cluster Puzzle titles compare to one another in terms of rarity and perceived value. It has also confirmed an optimistic "feeling" that I had. As compared to other puzzle auction sales in general, Cluster Puzzles do in fact enjoy a very significantly higher "sales success rate" at auction.
Of the thousands and thousands of jigsaw puzzles listed on eBay each year the average "sales success rate" is almost exactly 50%. That is to say half of all the puzzle auctions end without a sale. Some puzzle brands like Springbok, Parker/Pastime, Madmar and J.K. Straus, widely considered "collectible", stand out as having higher sales success rates in the 70% to 80% range. A handful of rare and high priced names like U-Nit, Tuck's, Burt and the astronomically costly PAR puzzles produce even higher numbers. Maybe not so surprisingly, the old Playboy Playmate jigsaw puzzles also have quite a high sales success rate.
I've documented 2831 Cluster Puzzle auctions (not including any of my own) since 2003. The numbers show that 2109 of them, about 74%, ended with a sale. This indicates to me that Cluster Puzzles are indeed perceived as desirable and "collectible" items...and with one big difference. They are still reasonably affordable.
Below are the results of the eBay auctions I have documented. I will try to keep this updated on a regular basis. I present the data only as a matter of interest. I cannot guarantee that I've documented ALL the auctions there have been, I could of easily missed others.
All Cluster Puzzle eBay Auctions - 12/15/2002 to 12/31/2024
# AUCTIONS # SOLD SUCCESS %
2831 2109 74.5%
2003 / 2004 AVG. $14.05
2005 / 2006 AVG. $18.22
2007 / 2008 AVG. $18.72
2009 / 2010 AVG. $17.48
2011 / 2012 AVG. $16.89
2013 / 2014 AVG. $18.80
2015 / 2016 AVG. $20.36
2017 / 2018 AVG. $19.41
2019 / 2020 AVG. $25.15
2021 / 2022 AVG. $33.04
2023 / 2024 AVG. $30.01
Individual Cluster Puzzle Titles:
Animals (#1) Highest: $56.00 Lowest: $0.99
# AUCTIONS # SOLD SUCCESS % AVG. $
702 506 72.1% $19.87
Figments(#2) Highest: $89.99 Lowest: $0.99
# AUCTIONS # SOLD SUCCESS % AVG. $
763 505 66.2% $19.22
Sports(#3) Highest: $76.00 Lowest: $2.50
# AUCTIONS # SOLD SUCCESS % AVG. $
280 223 79.6% $21.70
Make-Up(#4) Highest: $81.03 Lowest: $1.25
# AUCTIONS # SOLD SUCCESS % AVG. $
252 203 80.6% $21.70
Doodles(#5) Highest: $80.00 Lowest: $2.99
# AUCTIONS # SOLD SUCCESS % AVG. $
322 249 77.3% $21.86
Whimsies(#6) Highest: $62.95 Lowest: $1.99
# AUCTIONS # SOLD SUCCESS % AVG. $
155 143 92.3% $23.30
Unlikely Story #1 Highest: $94.43 Lowest: $2.15
# AUCTIONS # SOLD SUCCESS % AVG. $
54 37 68.5% $31.35
Cluster Puzzles (3 puzzle set) Highest: $280.00 Lowest: $0.99
# AUCTIONS # SOLD SUCCESS % AVG. $
303 243 80.2% $34.30
We love to hear from you. If you feel inspired, drop us an email message at: info@azplerp.com
